Revenge Concept as Manifested in Drawings and Narratives of Ultra-orthodox vs. Secular Israeli Jews

Authors

  • Rachel Lev-Wiesel Professor, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel Hai College, Israel
  • Iris Manor Binyamini Assoc. Prof., Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel Hai College, Israel
  • Michal Divon Schreiber Lecturer, Bar-Ilan University, Israel
  • Gideon Biran Social Worker, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel-Hai College, Israel
  • Zohar Estrin Social Worker, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel-Hai College, Israel
  • Gal Goldstein Social Worker, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel-Hai College, Israel
  • Nir Yosef Shmerts Social Worker, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel-Hai College, Israel
  • Shahar Nov Social Worker, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel-Hai College, Israel
  • Tali Beja Social Worker, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel-Hai College, Israel
  • Maya Gallor Social Worker, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel-Hai College, Israel
  • Odeya Landesman Sofer Social Worker, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel-Hai College, Israel
  • Lital Miran Social Worker, Research Center for Innovation in Social Work, Tel-Hai College, Israel
  • Bussakorn Binson Professor, FAA-Emili Sagol Creative Arts Research & Innovation for Well-being Center, Chulalongkorn University, Thailand.
  • Nisara Jaroenkajornkij Lecturer, FAA-Emili Sagol Creative Arts Research & Innovation for Well-being Center, Chulalongkorn University, Thailand

Keywords:

Revenge; Drawings; Self-figure Drawings; Narratives; Ultra-orthodox; Secular; Israelis

Abstract

The current study investigates the revenge concept of ultra-orthodox and secular Israeli Jews, manifesting in drawings and narratives. The convenient sample consisted of thirty-three participants aged 23-61 (12 ultra-orthodox and 21 seculars). This mix-methodology study included the qualitative part, which are two sets of drawings and narratives – “draw an unjust event you experienced” and “draw what you would prefer to happen to the person who unjustly treated you;” and the quantitative part included a self-report questionnaire of the following measures: demographics, history of traumatic events, and feelings of injustice. Comparison between the two groups revealed no differences in the drawings and narratives, however, Orthodox Jews reported higher exposure to sexual abuse. The sexual abuse group showed a significant tendency to include words and physical touch between the victim and the perpetrator in the first drawing. A level of narrative organization was low in those with a history of sexual abuse.

Downloads

Published

2023-12-21

How to Cite

Lev-Wiesel, Rachel, Iris Manor Binyamini, Michal Divon Schreiber, Gideon Biran, Zohar Estrin, Gal Goldstein, Nir Yosef Shmerts, Shahar Nov, Tali Beja, Maya Gallor, Odeya Landesman Sofer, Lital Miran, Bussakorn Binson, and Nisara Jaroenkajornkij. 2023. “Revenge Concept As Manifested in Drawings and Narratives of Ultra-Orthodox Vs. Secular Israeli Jews”. Journal of Urban Culture Research 27 (December):205-25. https://so04.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/JUCR/article/view/269599.